March 11, 2005

New York Public Library at it again.

The New York Public Library is at it again. First, it was the Che watches for sale at their "giift" shop. Now, it seems this bastion of freedom of speech and intellectual propriety is again offending the Cuban American Community.(subscription. I posted the rest of the article below the fold)

Less than three months after provoking outrage among Cuban Americans for selling a watch bearing the image of Che Guevara, the New York Public Library has offended some members of that community again by making "An Affair in Havana" the theme of this year's Young Lions Benefit gala.

The library's press release says the event will celebrate "literary Havana" and Ernest Hemingway. "Live samba music, expertly mixed mojitos and authentic
Cuban cuisine will bring a dose of la vida Cubana to Fifth Avenue at The New York Public Library Young Lions Benefit," it promises. The Young Lions is a group of under-40 donors to the library. Proceeds from the benefit - to be held April 21 - will go to the International Fiction Fund, dedicated to the maintenance and preservation of the library's collections.

Here's a message to the New York Public Library:

If you're going to use the quaintness of Cuba and her culture and her little brown people to promote one of your causes, get it fucking right assholes. The fucking "samba" isnt fucking Cuban, you pricks.

The Sun article continued:

Those collections include various Hemingway originals, and these, according to the coordinator of the Young Lions program, Katie Sanderson, were part of the inspiration for the benefit's theme. There was also the appeal of Havana itself: "Cuba is a place that does conjure up really sexy, exotic images, as a place to really get away," Ms. Sanderson said. "... For us to capture something so beautiful and exotic is very appealing."

The theme of last year's dinner and dance, Ms. Sanderson added, was Truman
Capote's "Black and White Ball," an event she called "a formal, serious
thing."
This year, she said, "It is important to do something a little freer, more
lighthearted in some ways."

Cuba is anything but "free" and "lighthearted," in the view of the president
of the Free Society Project, Maria Werlau, whose group is a nonprofit
human-rights organization documenting the victims of Cuba's communist
revolution.
Literary Havana is especially unsuitable as a party theme, she said, because
there
is currently no literary Havana to speak of, owing to heavy state censorship
and the lack of a free library system on the island. Those who have
attempted
to run independent libraries out of their homes have often met with
imprisonment and torture.

"It's insensitive to present Cuba like that when the reality of Cuba is so
different - it's like taking an aspect of Iraq or the Nazi government and
glamorizing it," Ms. Werlau, who was born in Cuba and moved to America as an
infant,
said.

The library's attitude toward its selected theme is probably bred of
ignorance, she said. But "since it's the library" - an intellectual and
academic

institution - "they shouldn't be ignorant of the state of culture in Cuba,
of
what's going on," she said.

A columnist for the Village Voice who has been an outspoken critic of
American librarians' indifference to the plight of their Cuban counterparts,
Nat

Hentoff, expressed similar outrage.

"If you take something out of history in what is now and has been for so
long
a dictatorship, and thereby give the illusion that this was a moment in time
that had no disastrous consequences - consequences totally against the
spirit
of what they're trying to portray - then that's being stupid," Mr. Hentoff,
who has urged the New York Public Library to support independent libraries
in
Cuba, said.

The author of "Fidel: Hollywood's Favorite Tyrant," Humberto Fontova, said
the library is taking part in an effort by Hollywood and other cultural
institutions to tap into the "coolness cachet" of Cuba and the regime there.
But

presenting a whitewashed image of Cuba to an American public "completely
ignorant"
of the true conditions on the island harms efforts to secure freedom there,
Mr. Fontova said.

A more political motive may also be behind the library's choice of a theme,
said the author, who was born in Cuba and fled the island for American
shores
in 1961.

Fidel Castro's top priority now, Mr. Fontova said, is "the really big push
to
end the so-called U.S. embargo." So the whole point of the library's
selecting Cuba as a theme, he added, "is to make people feel good about Cuba
and
feel
like 'Gosh, I'd sure love to visit that place - isn't it terrible that we
can
visit Red China and Vietnam and we can't visit Cuba?' "
"That's what they're trying to do here, I can almost guarantee you," Mr.
Fontova said.

The library's Ms. Sanderson, however, said the "Affair in Havana" was
intended only to provide fun and excitement. In making Cuba the benefit's
theme,
the
library and the gala's co-chairs were "savvy enough to know that it can be
quite controversial," she said. But in organizing a party, Ms. Sanderson
said,
"Inherently, you do only focus on the beautiful aspects of something, or the
fantasy aspects of something."

Ms. Werlau said she hopes the library will find a new theme for the gala. If
it doesn't, however, she said she expects the institution to portray more
than
the "beautiful" or "fantasy aspects" of Cuba.

Ms. Sanderson said, however, that the library does not currently plan to
recognize Cuban dissidents and authors at the benefit.

When asked whether the library would consider allocating some of the
benefit's proceeds to supporting independent libraries in Cuba, the deputy
manager of
public relations for the institution, Herb Scher, said he didn't think the
New
York Public Library was allowed to raise funds for other organizations.

"This party is for a very specific purpose. ... It's to get people involved
with the library," he said.
Ms. Werlau said that if the library fails to acknowledge that it is
presenting a falsely positive image of an oppressed nation, there might be
repercussions from the Cuban-American community.

"We might be forced to hold a demonstration to show the people attending the
gala what the reality of Cuba really is, or what Cuba in the '50s has
become,"
she said.


Posted by Val Prieto at March 11, 2005 01:31 PM



Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.babalublog.com/cgi-bin/mt/hut.cgi/1460

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference New York Public Library at it again.:

» MORE CASTRO ROMANTICIZING from Publius Pundit
Val Prieto at the excellent Babalu Blog is performing a public service by holding the New York Library accountable for its new bout of Castro worship. He isn't going to let their dewey-eyed support for the hemisphere's most brutal tyrant go uncriticize... [Read More]

Tracked on March 12, 2005 01:52 PM

Comments

Come on, Val. You know that's a typo - instead of samba they meant salsa. Oh, uh, well ....

Let's try again - maybe they meant a son. Although I doubt the polite, correct society folks would know how to handle an evening of sons.If they listened to a few, maybe they'd have the cojones to kick fidel's ass.

Posted by: Juan Paxety at March 11, 2005 01:48 PM

one word: stupidity.

Posted by: Felix Ricardo at March 11, 2005 01:56 PM

Friggin unbelievable.

Posted by: Kathleen at March 11, 2005 02:15 PM

I sent this to a large list of Cuban Americans in New York City and I hope they will at least protest. Unfortunatly the Cuban American community in NYC is not known for protesting things like this. They don't listen to me - even when I send them tons of notices like this. They don't know how to do it too well and the Anglo urban types who go to events like this end up making fun of us. Besides for this to take on heat and the Cuban American community to go ballistic the order of protest would have to come from someone well known or an organization. I am a little guy and no one wants to listen to me - so most of these things in NYC go ignored by the Cuban American community because they say - who are you Mandingo? It's a shame though. This thing really needs to be protested! I don't know how many pro Castro events I find out about and I send things to the big NYC Cuban list and no one does anything! Last month an agent from the UN Cuban mission went to a Long Island public library to speak about the "wonders" of the revolution - I am not making this up - and I sent tons and tons of e-mails to all I knew to protest this. NOT ONE RESPONSE - NO ONE PROTESTED! I almost want to give up sometimes.

Thanks to Val for understanding how the Castro folks work and letting the whole rest of the world know.

Posted by: mandingo jones at March 11, 2005 02:34 PM

Maybe instead of "An affair in Havana," they should re-title it "Prostituiting Havana." That is, after all, what they're doing by using Havana in order to make a profit. And like prostitution, there is no regard to the actual individual, which is why I understand them screwing something up as basic as Samba (which is Brazilian) instead of Salsa... or even Son... or Conga... or Rumba... or Guaracha... or Guaguanco... Palo... Mambo... Bolero... and even Cha-Cha-Cha.

They have a feast of music to choose from, and their choice of Samba say's it all. They're a bunch of ignorant-commie-pimps.

Posted by: Songuacassal at March 11, 2005 03:09 PM

this cuban is laughing his ass off
La samba hhahahhehehe

Posted by: Ed Perez-Pantoja at March 11, 2005 03:46 PM

I just LOVED this quote:
"If you're going to use the quaintness of Cuba and her culture and her little brown people to promote one of your causes, get it fucking right assholes. The fucking "samba" isn’t fucking Cuban, you pricks"

The following MAY sound as a put down on NY BUT.... IT AINT. It is just the results of a HUGE melting pot that hasn’t quite melted YET!

Last night i was watching a video by Eddie Izzard (in MY opinion the best standup EVER!) Taped in NYC and one of the routines made some obscure references to Europe and there was this strange " um, er what ??" kindd hush from the crowd.. To which Izzard responded" Do YOU guys know what I am talking about... ? hmmm do you EVEN know there are OTHER countries?"
In NYC we are ALL guilty of some terrible ethnic faux-pass at some point in our lives. Calling a Pakistani, Indian is a popular fuck up.
I was extremely embarrassed recently when someone I have known for years (Afghani) straightened me out on the fact that Afghanis are classified as Caucasian... Damn if I knew.
When I first came to NYC Cuban was synonymous with Puerto Rican and Vice versa.
It is REALLY amazing how little we know of each other’s cultures in NYC. Even at the highest “cultural” levels you find people who WILL believe that a Samba IS Cuban music or that a Mambo is Mexican music.
Sometimes it is pathetic; like someone at the Guggenheim museum (rather stuffy old lady) asked me (when I mentioned I was Cuban) “Picasso was Cuban, wasn’t he?” Hey (hell with it I said) YES HE WAS CUBAN!
My take is that to her "Spanish" and "Cuban" meant the same thing.


Posted by: KillCastro at March 11, 2005 04:07 PM

Songuacassal,
Very well said.

Posted by: lmh at March 11, 2005 04:09 PM

And this Anglo-Saxon yelled "Samba!!??" and woke up the dang cat.

Posted by: Grace at March 11, 2005 04:12 PM


Picasso; Cuban, cubist. Same thing, right?

Posted by: homebru at March 11, 2005 05:08 PM

**snort** I love the ignorance of the socially self-assured.... It's the Library. They must be right (NOT)

Posted by: caltechgirl at March 11, 2005 05:08 PM

This is what I wrote to ksanderson@nypl.org (deals with the Young Lions activities at the NY Public Library)

I think that your celebration of Cuba is wrong, totally wrong.
Why is that I am such a party spoiler?
Because what you are celebrating is a repressive regime, headed by a bloodthirsty tyrant who has a knack for attacking the freedom of expression, the freedom of creativity and the freedom of thought of the Cuban people...
How are you celebrating that? By not denouncing that regime, by not having the courage of supporting the independent librarians in Cuba.
It's wrong to celebrate Cuban literature without condemning those who oppress its creators. Reynaldo Arenas died a New Yorker. He couldn't live as a Cuban... And Jose Marti was a New Yorker for most of his adult life, and is properly honored in Central Park. His statue is crying because of the lamentable spectacle of the NY Public Library consorting with a murderous dictator, those droplets aren't molten snow, they are called tears.
Please, remember the Cuban writers who are dying far from their land because they cannot express themselves with the same freedom you have here in their native country. Remember Cabrera Infante, remember all the monuments of Cuban literature that cannot be read in Cuba because the monster who rules Cuba decided that censorship was the way to deal with free spirits.
As a footnote, samba is Brazilian, not Cuban. But if the parents of the idea of celebrating Cubanness as sex and mojitos don't know much about the plight of the Cuban people they probably don't know a lot about Cuban music... Do they know about solitary cells for artists and writers? Do they know about repression and destruction of families? About executions and prison for dissidents? Do they know about prison for poets for the only sin of thinking independently?
Do they care?
Please be informed that I dropped my library card where I am not going to find it anymore.
Please be informed that your actions are deeply insulting...
Why don't you also have a SS Black Leather Night? Cabarets in Nazi Germany were fun, weren't them?
For a Cuban, fidel castro (not capitalized) is his or her homegrown Hitler. His dictatorship is our own homegrown Holocaust. So your celebration is as offensive as it would be a celebration celebrating nazi-fascism or as a celebration to read the verses of Osama Bin Laden, and yes it's as un-American as it could be. As it is to sell watches with the efigy and likelyness of an anti-American murderer Che Guevara.

Sincerely
C.B.

I sent them copy of the posting Tale of Two Libraries...

Posted by: CB at March 11, 2005 05:19 PM

Hey, they may be right, after all, the samba WILL become Cuban after Lula hands over Brazil to castro.
As to the folks at the NY library, I myself, just refuse to have a battle of wits with unarmed persons.
AS to the NY home boys, they're letting those libs up there contaminate them, voting for Hillary and all.
Thats why some of them post here saying they want to go to DC and pressure the administration to let them cuddle up with castro and his animals.

Posted by: cohetedude at March 11, 2005 08:21 PM

Cubism --> Cuba. Hmmmmmm

Okay, we ARE taking credit for it, screw Picasso!

Actually there is some strange connections between Picasso and Cuba. Do a Google search for +Picasso +Cuba +"Wilfredo Lam". It IS interesting
Lam was a young Cuban painter who became a very close friend of Picasso’s in Paris and some of Lam's native Cuban influences (mostly African style painting. His mom was a "Santera") DID make it to some of Picasso's work.
After all Picasso DID say “Average painters copy, GREAT painters STEAL”

Also... There is a Picasso family in Cuba. Picasso’s grandfather migrated to Cuba and “married” a local black girl, hence forming what has been known as "The Black Picassos"
Pablo Picasso found it amusing he had a whole side of his family that was of mixed race. Often promising to visit, but never did.
But, I STILL don’t see how an educated "art lover" (wealthy no less) would make such ridiculous mistake.

Posted by: KillCastro at March 11, 2005 11:48 PM

Proceeds from the benefit will go to the International Fiction Fund

How appropriate

Posted by: Cindy at March 12, 2005 08:58 AM

The theme of last year's dinner and dance, Ms. Sanderson added, was Truman Capote's "Black and White Ball," an event she called "a formal, serious thing."
Serious enough that her intellect rivals that of Paris Hilton.
There must have been some inbreeding somewhere along the line.

Posted by: Fausta at March 12, 2005 10:46 AM

Scene: Sidewalk outside benefit.

A row of cages with one adult in each cage.
c
"I'm a librarian in Cuba."

"Help us."

"They burnt our books and threw us in prison for operating libraries independent of the government."

"This is 'An Affair in Havana' right now!"

"Please remember us when you drink your mojitos."

"In Cuba, they jail librarians who refuse to censor books."

"Right now, there are X number of librarians in jail. Excuse me, sir, ma'am, would you like to know more about the librarians in Cuba before you celebrate tonight?"

Literature, photos & testimonials handed to each patron on their way into the fund raiser.

Who's up for a quick trip to NYC?--scott

Posted by: jsb at March 12, 2005 01:04 PM

I am so outrageously pissed.

This is like holding a Political Fundraiser in 1942 focusing on the 'intrigue and danger' of the Warsaw, or a costume party in '92 entitled 'One Night in Kurdistan'.

Insufferable pricks in their ivory towers. Jesus.

Posted by: Foster at March 12, 2005 02:14 PM

is the nyc public library planing on sending the profits from this event to the independent libraries in cuba?

Posted by: jlopez at March 12, 2005 03:51 PM

You know, I recall my folks telling me that all Latin American music (with the exception of Mexican Ranchera/Banda) came from Cuba. And after fidel, Cuba's place in music was lost. This is obviously "Cubancentrist" and of course true. Now, in regards to Samba in Cuba, solamente recuerdo un musico Cubano llamado Perez Prado, who combined Samba with Mambo. Anyhow, that doesn't prove Samba came from Cuba, but in the spirit of "Cubancentrism" I will say that not only is Picasso and Cubist art obviously Cuban, but hell so is Samba and by the way the Italians took friggin espresso from us. Cojones.

Posted by: Songuacassal at March 13, 2005 01:17 AM

Songuacassal:
GOD damn that was funny ! And, I don’t think anyone wants to take credit for Rancheras!

Okay, Let’s push the Cubacentrism even further.

This is a personal experience and do not know the roots of this “myth”

YEARS ago I lived in London for a brief while and got to know the owner of a tiny little bookstore devoted primary to mystical stuff ( I was in my mystical period then, so were a LOT of gorgeous London girls --- YOU make the connection )

So, speaking to the owner of the shop I mentioned I was Cuban.. And without flinching the old fellow said knowingly “ah, one of the lost tribes…” . The refernce did not mean ANYTHING to me so he went to explain about the 10 lost tribes of Israel and how one of them had wound up in the Caribbean area, there forming the mythical city of Atlantis. Amongst mystics most likely Cuba was the MAIN island of Atlantis AND that the western most point of Atlantis was in fact Pinar del Rio. Amongst the cognoscenti there were a lot of facts in Plato’s narration and other civilizations that pointed to Pinar del Rio as a crucial clue as to the location of Atlantis.

Now, this old bookshop owner was in fact of Jewish descent, had NEVER been to Cuba, had never even met a Cuban before meeting me.
He was quite disappointed when I explained to him I actually was BORN in Cuba but did not have any Cuban blood since both my parents were Spaniards, still he found my connection to Cuba quite intriguing and attributed a LOT of the extraordinary excellence that comes out of the island to the fact that perhaps Cuba was indeed blessed with some kind of mystical powers. Just the Cuban soil is EXCEPTIONAL unique in the world. As far as I know no other place in the world you find "Tierra ColorấH"

Let’s face it, we have (disproportionably) contributed a LOT more to the world in terms of sports , arts, letters, music, even FOOD , that our small size would likely produce. I mean you do not know of any “German” restaurants and Russian music hasn’t REALLY taken off in a big way. In Sports we were kicking everybody’s butt way before Castro made sports an international communist propaganda campaign

The unusual way in which foreigners LOVE the island is quite poignant. Spaniards still moan over the loosing of Cuba. When something is totally hopeless a Spaniard will still say “So what, we lost Cuba so how bad could this be”. To jump in a taxi in Taiwan and hear Benny More blasting on the radio is just kindda surreal!

Even in 2005 there is a mystical quality to the Island that we Cubans have experienced and that foreigners seem to instinctively love.

Well let’s fast forward to about 4 years ago when I see the headline. “ATLANTIS FOUND OFF THE ISLAND OF CUBA”

There are a couple of books to this fact at Amazon. I read one of them and was blown away at the facts. Indeed a cave in Pinar del Rio matches to a *T* (I never understood what matching to a *T* meant) one of the most descriptive holy places in Atlantis.

Again, this is as “CUBACENTRIC” as you can get (and a lot of non-Cubans are gonna go "there THEY go AGAIN) but it is there, and quite available for those willing to Google +Cuba +Atlantis.

I leave it up to you all to come up with your own conclusion ;)


Posted by: KillCastro at March 13, 2005 03:01 PM

Killcastro, add to that that the island is also world traveled, they had a nature flick on PBS not too long ago on Cuban wildlife which stared that Cuba was formed in the Pacific ocean and traveled westward before the central American istmus existed and is came to rest where it is now. Figure that one out!

Posted by: cohetedude at March 14, 2005 02:27 AM

ATLANTIS??? WOW!!! Coño why stop there? It's been said by some experts that Atlantis was a metaphor for the lost Garden of Eden. Therefore, in the spirit of Cubacentrism, Cuba is Atlantis and Atlantis is really the lost Garden of Eden, thus Cuba is actually the lost Garden of Eden! There, now Cuba is in Bible.

Posted by: Songuacassal at March 14, 2005 12:19 PM

cohetedude:
Was formed in the "PACIFIC" and traveled west ward or was form in the pacific traveled eastward and then the itsmus closed ?
If it was formed in the PACIFIC and traveld westward to where it is today that would be (in typical Naw Yawkah lingo... a muddafuckah!)
One notable thing here is that the only place in the world that I have seen with exactly the same fruits as we have in Cuba is Taiwan!

No real explnation for this but they have, mamoncillo, guanabana, chirimoyas, zapote etc etc etc... and even the NAMES of the fruits sound similar as what we call them in Cuba!

Posted by: KillCastro at March 14, 2005 12:30 PM

Killcastro, no kiddin' mi socio, I saw it with my own two baby blues in PBS. Horita nos van a comvertir en chinos o hawaianos tambien! Que barbaridad!

Posted by: cohetedude at March 14, 2005 08:48 PM

Songuacassal
Hmmm it goes deeper than THAT!
If Atlantis was the garden of Eden and Cuba was Atlantis then human life itself BEGAN in CUBA !
No wonder they say Adam and Eve WERE cubans
why ?
They didn’t have clothes to wear, they only had fruit to eat, they couldn’t leave the garden. And they called it paradise.

But... all kidding aside, the Cuba = Atlantis thing is actually a REAL theory
check this out :
http://andrewcollins.com/page/articles/atlantiscuba.htm


Posted by: KillCastro at March 14, 2005 09:31 PM

cohetedude
Hatuey had that "chinese" look to him. Nice head too!
I still don’t see how in hell Cuba traveled WESTWARD from the pacific to where it is today. Unless someone on board had a GPS and one HELL of an outboard motor.

But if PBS says so….
This is the same PBS that keeps exalting the fact that Castro got rid of Batista , uh? ;)

(Deep PBS announcer voice)
“In 1959 Fidel Castro and his band of rebels, rid Cuba of the tyrannical oppression of the USA backed government of Fulgencio Batista”

PBS has a unique way of distilling historical facts to the most simplistic (and asinine) sound bites.

Posted by: KillCastro at March 14, 2005 09:44 PM

hahaha... Good one KillCastro.

Besides, life did begin in Cuba and I think that's something that we all knew and just kept to ourselves. Well... that and that God is Cuban, so I guess Samba is an obivious and petty claim! (I guess this would also make castro Satan?)

As for Atlantis, I wasn't kidding about researchers relating it to the Garden of Eden. However, Alantis = Cuba? That's news! I seem to remember hearing that Atlantis was part of American Continent that was once close to the Iberian Penninsula, and as it floated away it looked like it was sinking. Anyhow, I'll go ahead and check your link. Gracias.

Posted by: Songuacassal at March 15, 2005 08:24 PM

Bueno, killcastro, Adam and Eve may have been Cuban, but God definitely was! A Supreme Being que le saca una costilla por la gandinga a un tipo medio bobo pa hacer a una jeva y despues le da ella una manzanita, (puede haber sido un mamey) para que con esa lo joda, ese sentido de humor es Cubano, ni lo dudes.

Posted by: cohetedude at March 15, 2005 08:53 PM