July 12, 2005
Civil Society To Cuba's Rescue
Investor's Business Daily
Tuesday, July 12, 2005
Democracy: As Cuba digs out from one of the worst hurricanes ever to hit the island, Fidel Castro faces a new challenge to his tyranny. It's not just the failure of Cuba's infrastructure. It's also what's filling the void.
That something is the use of technology as a lifeline to the construction of a civil society. As Hurricane Dennis slammed through Cuba, an interesting change happened: Cubans lost their fear of the state and provided minute-by-minute reporting about conditions by cell phone, e-mail or short-wave radio on the hurricane to their Miami brethren.
The unprecedented firsthand reports went beyond mere human connection and into the realm of spontaneously constructing a civil society as Miami Cubans now mobilize to send aid. It's like farmers helping each other build barns, the first outline of an emerging polity. And all this is from the hurricane rubble and the failures of Castro's regime. These private efforts not only provide aid; they also establish civil institutions. And the U.S. should encourage it.
There's never been anything like it. Reports rolled in not just from Havana, but from citizens in Santa Clara, Matanzas, Cienfuegos and Santiago, and these reports made their way onto the Internet.
Stories are unconfirmed, but ordinary Cubans told what they knew, and we heard reports of a Cuban Coast Guard cutter going down, Ernest Hemingway's house getting slammed, fish in the Havana streets blown in by waves gathered as food by hungry locals, art collections damaged, the need for candles amid power outages, the forced government evacuations and those who hid from them, the preferentialism given to rich European and Canadian tourists (and Cuban citizen protests as half-empty tourist evacuation buses rolled by), the looting of government shops in cities, the disjointed radio babblings of Fidel Castro on the "mercenary" hurricane, the weird hurricane parties. Not one word of this ever made Cuba's government-controlled press or, with the exception of the Miami Herald, the mainstream U.S. media.
Cuba is one of the world's most closed societies, so to read these accounts for the first time was an amazing change. We expected nothing but propaganda from the official media.
Only the most privileged members of Cuban society have access to the Internet and other technology, so the fact that even they were willing to use it to issue candid reports about hurricane damage shows that Castro's control is fading.
But something else is taking its place. As Cuban-Americans get these unprecedented reports from their relatives, they are struggling to find a way to extend a hand to the devastated without Castro's operatives getting their hands on the aid. That in itself is citizen action that will prove to be a building block of civil society, and it signals a vast reservoir of social capital in Cuba that's building.
These Miami citizens, groups like Democracia Movement, are making an effort to fill the void from the Castro government's neglect and indifference. Private citizens are reaching out to other private citizens in Cuba and doing things for themselves. It's how democracies take root. And it further confirms that Cuba is on the edge of shaking off its dictatorship, and Castro, as outgoing U.S. envoy James Cason said, "is on his last legs."
This welcome step toward civil initiatives should be encouraged. Private U.S. citizens should be given at least a temporary window to help other private citizens in Cuba as they struggle to dig out from Dennis' rubble. Because the Cuban government, on its last legs, isn't going to do it. These civic ties that bind are Cuba's real future.
http://www.investors.com/editorial/issues02.asp?v=7/12
Editor's note:More on this topic at The 26th Parallel.
Posted by Mora at July 12, 2005 06:57 PM
Comments
These are the happiest tears I've cried in a long time. Viva Libre Cuba!!!
Posted by: Kathleen at July 12, 2005 07:13 PM
I dont necessarily think allowing a bunch of people to go to Cuba now, under the auspices of Hurricane Aid, is a good thing.
Shortage of food, lack of potable water, bad sanitary conditions. More poeple on the island just compounds the problems. Creating an organization, possibly with a credible humanitarian organization, under the eyes of the world, would help get supplies to those in need and we'd have some kind of confirmation or assurance that the aid did, in fact, go where needed. Otherwise, its all ultimately money in fidel's pockets.
Posted by: Val Prieto at July 12, 2005 07:28 PM
Val - I so agree. The most important thing is that it doesn't touch castro's fetid hands. If private organizations can do that, good, if public organizations can do that, good, if secret organizations can do that, good, if informal organizations can do that, good. None of this Red-Cross sell-the-stuff-to-the-locals to finance castro's dollar shops stuff that currently goes on. Aid only if aid goes to those in need.
Memo to castro: That doesn't mean you.
Posted by: A.M. Mora y Leon at July 12, 2005 07:36 PM
That is why I am going myself,to make sure what I take goes from my hands,to my families hands,it is the way it should be anyway, no need for any organization to take on the resposibility and obligation that we are born with as a member of a family.
Posted by: YUCA at July 12, 2005 08:20 PM
Val's point makes sense. Too many people in Cuba at once would create more disorganization, make direct transfer of aid harder and more liable to get to fidel's hands.
A controlled, monitored relief effort led by a credible organization is the best way. The fund initiated by CANF is a good start.
Posted by: Robert at July 12, 2005 08:22 PM
I've been thinking about this for a while and maybe some influential people can pick up the idea. Distribute cellphones to Cubans, best would be camera phones.
Cubans are not allowed to register cellphones, but they can use phones registered by foreigners. So here's the idea:
Trustworthy tourists could take the cam phones to Cuba, buy a few Cubacel cards and distribute the phones to trustworthy Cubans, preferably those who get around a lot. Whenever something interesting happens they can send an SMS out and of course they can be called. I don't know if MMS works in Cuba but if it does, pics could be sent, too.
It would be very difficult for Castro to shut this down. The phones are registered to foreigners who have already left Cuba (pick people who are not likely to return). OK, some accounts will be shut down but any foreigner would be able to register a new Cubacel account.
Phones must be GSM. Maybe we could get Motorola to sponsor this? (Think about building up a brand name in a future democratic Cuba). The Cubacel card would cost about 70$ registration (includes 40$ worth), additional cards can be bought for 40$
Free flow of information is the worst that can happen to a dictator.
Posted by: Eleggua at July 12, 2005 08:30 PM
LACK OF POTABLE WATER, UNSANITARY CONDITIONS, SHORTAGE OF FOOD...
STOP! WHY ARE WE THINKING OF SENDING CUBANS FROM HERE???
LETS ASK JESSE JACKSON, DICK DURBIN, SEN HILLARY CLINTON,BARBRA STREISSAND, SEAN PENN, MICHAEL MOORE, ETC ETC, TO LEAD THE DELEGATION GO TO CUBA AND BRING AID TO THE PEOPLE IN THE ISLAND AFTER DENNIS!!
DON'T FORGET THEY MUST DRINK THE SAME WATER, EAT THE SAME FOOD.
POSTED BY MY EVIL TWIN!
Posted by: CARMEN at July 12, 2005 10:24 PM
My earlier crying post was an emotional reaction to the idea of Cubans enjoying some free speech. If anyone goes to help I think it should be pastors for peace and members of the NCC, working side by side with the locals in the hardest hit areas, and like Carmen said, eating the same food, drinking the same water, enjoying real Cuban accommodations, for a mandatory period of time like maybe a year or two. There's a lot of work to be done. Maybe dan rather would like to go with them and cover it.
Posted by: Kathleen at July 12, 2005 11:01 PM
The author of that article seems to have been reading Babalu. :)
I think allowing people to go, whether with an aid group or individually, would foster HOPE which is as important as water and food. These helpers, like YUCA, wouldn't be arriving empty-handed to be parasites like the tourists usually do. They'd bring food and medicine, water filters and purification tablets, whatever they could pack or smuggle in. Together with the Cubans, they'll figure out what to do because Cubans have always been resourceful that way, right? It wouldn't be easy or pretty, but it could really affect the dynamic of the general population to make the move to democracy faster and stronger. --Not overtly of course, but anything that can bolster the underground freedom movement is good in the long run. And armed with cameras and cell phones, they could show the world the real Cuba in a big way.
Yes, as important as the help they would bring, an influx of "outsiders" would be another crack in castro's closed society. Perhaps it would even be the straw that breaks the camel's back which is why castro refused Bush's official offer for hurricane aid.
Posted by: FL Mom at July 13, 2005 07:19 AM
There's an interesting article here: http://enlayuma.com/node/28#comment-23?PHPSESSID=62509411119c4e8c061ec8977724a1a8
about how the US government offered humanitarian aid after Dennis, and how after Castro rejected it, the state department is now funneling it through various NGO's.. I wonder which organizations they will use..
Posted by: Pedro at July 13, 2005 12:46 PM
If you take the time to call the International RED CROSS, they will tell you that the ONLY country in the world where humanitarian aid MUST reach the population through the government and as the government seems fit is…… Ta-da KUBA!
So anything that we can send to KaSStro’s Kuba will somehow be tainted by his bloody hands.
My own family in La Habana PROHIBITED me to send anything, cause they would NOT see it.
And a little point of contention here.
When the USA offers $50K of humanitarian help… that is a pre-assigned number that can be given to any country on a no–questions-asked-come-to-the embassy-and-I’ll give –you-the-cash basis. It does NOT mean that is the ONLY money the USA is willing to send to the country in question. But alas, in typical senile , egocentrically, my Depends are so full of it I cant even move form KaSStro doesn’t need any AID.
See if 40,000 Cubans die (and who REALLY knows how many Cubans have and will die) that’s 40,000 mouths he doesn’t need to feed.
Think of it this way. The Zoo keeper WANTS to keep the lions so weak; they will NOT have the energy to strike back.
AND …. It isn’t HIS fault Cubans are starving, it was the HURRICANE!
Blame it on the “Diabolic forces of Nature”
Brilliant in a Stalin, Hitler, Pol-Pot kindda way.
Posted by: KillCastro at July 13, 2005 03:34 PM
