August 10, 2006
A Message for the MSM
I had a conversation with a member of the MSM the other day regarding the coverage of Cuba. There are a few MSM organizations with bureaus in Cuba whose reporters walk a daily tightrope to bring coverage of the island nation to the world. These journalists have to strike a precarious balance: try to report on events in Cuba without offending the Cuban government lest they be expelled from the island nation.
And for a news organization, that is a difficult decision. Do they cover this particular story today, piss off the government and get thrown out and then miss the big story altogether? Lose the bureau and the only connection they have to report the goings on in the island?
I would like to say I cant blame them for deciding to either slant their coverage or allow it to be influenced by the government. But truth of the matter is that it's their responsibility to report the truth, to report the reality despite the consequences. And I lay some of the blame on the situation in Cuba squarely on their shoulders. Helping a criminal hide, after all, makes you an accomplice to his crime.
But redemption may be at hand right now. What we are witnessing in Cuba right now may be the beginning of much turmoil. If indeed the Cuban government is in a state of change, the possibility of much bloodshed exists moreso now than ever because the Cuban government will not relinquish its hold without brutality. They will fight tooth and nail. They will, as they have done for the past 47 years, eliminate anyone that poses a threat to their control.
It is up to those few journalists and reporters in Cuba to show the true nature of the Cuban government despite the consequences. Because if the world isnt privy to it, the repression, the attacks on the lives and dignity of the Cuban people, the abrogation of human and civil rights, will continue and yet another generation of people will suffer the same fate.
So to those members of the MSM, whom I have raked through the coals many a time, please, tell us the truth. If people are being beaten, tell us the truth. If people are being rounded up and jailed, tell us the truth. If fear is prevalent within the Cuban people, tell us the truth. If there is bloodshed, show it to us. Dont worry about being tossed from the island.
If it's the truth which you have reported, then a small part of you will always remain in Cuba. And if you should get thrown off the island, you have the conviction of knowing that you did what was right. And that young Cuban cab driver you know that has driven you around all this time will be all the better for it. And that Cuban old woman you've bought trinkets from will be all the better for it. And that little Cuban kid that runs errands for you will be all the better for it as you may have, indeed by your honest coverage of the events in Cuba, opened the door to his future as a free human being.
Posted by Val Prieto at August 10, 2006 08:47 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.babalublog.com/cgi-bin/mt/hut.cgi/3781
Comments
You're right Val,
If just one reporter did it, as a big scoop, even if he/she was thrown out. He/she'd become the big story and all would have to report it. Just one live feed of how things really are is all it probably takes.
Posted by: Lori
at August 10, 2006 09:52 AM
Don't hold your breath. When Mexican president Vicente Fox visited Cuba (a while back) he met with Cuban opposition leader Marta Beatriz Roque Cabello and members of the dissidence such as Vladimiro Roca.
The second President Fox left Cuba, the Cuban secret police went to Mrs. Roque's house beat her up, tore the clothes from her body and then draged her through the street to their military vehicle. Mrs. Roque is a woman in her 60s.
That same afternoon Lucia Newman from CNN Made no mention of the event as she was too busy reporting on a dog show taking place in Havana.
The only reason the Cuban-American community was made aware of this assault was through Mrs. Roque herself when she called a Cuban radio station in Miami after she was released.
Posted by: Firefly
at August 10, 2006 10:08 AM
Lucia Newman is an asshole.
Posted by: mario
at August 10, 2006 10:17 AM
The MSM that has official bureaus in Cuba has made a Faustian bargain with the devil that is castro. Like all Faustian bargains the reward isn't worth the price, but these short-sighted assholes don't know a damned thing about Faust or the devil.
Posted by: conductor
at August 10, 2006 10:41 AM
If just one does it, he makes all his competitors look really bad. He ought to do it for that alone.
Posted by: A.M. Mora y Leon
at August 10, 2006 10:43 AM
Val, this is the best and most important thing you have ever written!
Posted by: manny
at August 10, 2006 11:00 AM
While I understand that journalists walk a tight rope in Cuba and that they risk being thrown out of the country if they report the truth, how about when they come back to the USA after a stint in Cuba? Many of them still go on reporting the same half truths and repeating the same soundbites about the Cuban health care and education being so grand, and you never read any human interests stories about their life on a tightrope in Cuba. And remember Lucia Newman, after her disasterous stint in Cuba where she helped to prop up the dictatorship by talking about Cuba's beaches, old vintage cars and cigar festivals, etc.. she was interviewed and she was totally unrepetant and in fact spitful towards the exile community. She totally discarded the charge that she was only reporting fluff stories out of Cuba and said that the problem is that the Cuban exiles in Miami [whom she called rightwingers if I remember correctly] wanted her to slant her reporting in their favor and that she would not compromise her journalistic integrity to do that. What a bitch!
So, while reporters do walk a tightrope in Cuba, many of them I believe simply don't care to tell the truth. Who knows? Maybe Castro bribes them with jineteras in Varadero.
Wasn't there a story going around about some secret video with Lucia and a pinguero??
Posted by: Ray
at August 10, 2006 11:45 AM
Great Post
I’m sure most people who become journalists probably do so because they want to make a difference in the world by telling the truth and exposing injustice.
Journalism is a noble profession.
It’s great idea to remind the journalists in Cuba that we in the Cuban community are behind them and that all we ask is that they to tell the truth. Nothing more.
Posted by: Reinier A Potts
at August 10, 2006 12:17 PM
Here's an AP article from cnn.com that illustrates perfectly how the MSM in a subtle way endorses the arguments made by the regime:
http://edition.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/americas/08/10/cuba.espionage.ap/
Here's the excerpt:
On Wednesday, the full 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta, Georgia, with two judges dissenting, rejected the men's argument that pervasive community prejudice against the Cuban government and publicity surrounding the case prevented them from receiving a fair trail.
In Havana, the Communist Party daily Granma noted the ruling coincides with recent events in Cuba, where Fidel Castro temporarily ceded power to his brother Raul on July 31 after announcing he had undergone intestinal surgery.
"All of these occur in an unusual way and at a time when Miami is calling for an end to a sovereign nation," Granma said.
"This has been a political case from the beginning," Granma said, and demonstrates "hate and vengeance against the Cuban nation."
Here they take the statements of the Cuban government and report that as "news". There is no attempt to get a legal expert to comment on whether these accusations by Cuba have any merit. No attempt to talk to the prosecutor or a source inside the government. No explanation of how long it takes to process an appeal in Federal Court, what the procedures are and how and when decisions are published.
They just put a statement out there and nothing to counter it. It's garbage. It's either laziness or it's outright bias.
Posted by: conductor
at August 10, 2006 12:54 PM
http://www.latinamericanstudies.org/cuba/ap-bureau.htm
HAVANA, Cuba (Reuters) -- A fire apparently caused by an electrical malfunction gutted the Havana bureau of the U.S. news agency. . .
http://www.apbroadcast.com/AP+Broadcast/About+Us/Press+Releases/General/Gramling+Awards.htm
The other Gramling Achievement Award went to Chief of Bureau in Cuba, Anita Snow, who was cited for reopening the AP bureau in Havana. . .
Posted by: ligarcia
at August 10, 2006 01:34 PM
Val,
You know me, I am the "and the horse you rode in on" individual.
If your doing what you say your doing, why not give the people of Cuba some solace? Isn't it alright to say that help is coming? You won't be saying anything that the Cuban police don't know. Can't you tell them of subtle ways they can do passive resistance? Do you think that no one in Cuba is reading your blog?
Ray (Captain's Quarters)
Posted by: Ray
at August 10, 2006 02:41 PM
Journalism is supposed to just tell the truth or the facts about what is actually happening...but many western journalist are the biggest "whores" ever.
I don't see anything "noble" about just telling the truth. If they did their jobs, the world could decide what to think about Cuba. Lucia Newman has no "journalistic principles" or she wouldn't have been in Cuba in the first place.
Posted by: mavi
at August 10, 2006 03:16 PM
Brilliant commentary; should be printed worldwide.
Posted by: Grammy in Phila.
at August 10, 2006 05:44 PM
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

