November 05, 2007
Cuban Philosophizing
It’s frustrating to sit on this side of the puddle and wonder why the Cubans living on the other side just don’t do something. Anything!
Ok, so some kids wore some “cambio” bracelets and got arrested. Quietly. Big deal! Have you seen the protests in Venezuela? The hell with bracelets. We need protests like those. Thousands screaming with signs, tear gas, rubber bullets, brutality, beatings, blood.
Understanding the predicament of Cuban dissidents requires the aid of Cuban philosophy. In order to be a Cuban philosopher…well, all Cubans are philosophers, but to be a good Cuban philosopher, you have to be able to succinctly analyze the phenomenology of the specific reality being discussed and make a simple one-phrase pronouncement that breaks down the human condition to its essential existential component. (ok, so Cubans are good B.S.’ers too). So, I’m not a master of Cuban philosophy, but I’m going to take a stab at it anyway:
“El que esta fuera del agua, nada bien”
The opposition inside the island is weak, fragmented, infiltrated and virtually unknown. This is highlighted in this story from a Ray Sanchez article in Sunday’s Sun Sentinel.
More than 200 people had mobilized for the late September protest demandingfreedom for political prisoners. But state security agents intercepted many ofthe dissidents outside the capital and detained them for hours."People were picked up on roads; others were prevented from leaving their homes," said Martha Beatriz Roque, 62, one of the organizers. An economist by profession, Roque has pushed against the Castro government for 17 years and served two prison terms for her efforts.
In the end, only eleven people attended the peaceful demonstration outside Cuba's Justice Ministry. It quietly fizzled when police loaded the demonstrators on a bus and drove them home.
Is all the opposition in the island totally hapless and clueless? Hardly. In Cuba, every fifth person in any group is probably an informant, an undercover member of the MINIT, (interior ministry). It is impossible to organize large protests because of this. In order for a mass protest, like the ones occurring in Venezuela, to occur, thousands would have to spontaneously take the streets without planning because any planning would surely alert the regime through its network of informants. Still, dissidents keep on trying. 70 young people protesting elections with or without bracelets is something. It's incredible. Sisyphus had a better chance of getting the rock to stay on top of the hill.- “No hay peor diligencia que la que no se haga”
Just how does the regime keep track of and control the opposition in order to thwart their regime change plans?
Well, for years we exiles have been saying that Cuba’s repressive machine is brutally effective and omnipotent, one of the worse in the “Soviet Block”. In this Miami Herald article, we learn that the Cuban Ministry of the Interior learned its repressive ways from the “best”, the West German Stasi, according to Jorge Luís Vázquez:
Headquartered amid the grim Soviet-styled apartment blocks of the former East Berlin, the Stasi -- short for Staatssicherheit, or State Security -- succeeded through surveillance, intimidation and torture in becoming one of the most feared intelligence agencies in the world. By the time the Berlin Wall collapsed in 1989, the Stasi had 91,000 employees and 350,000 collaborators in a country of 17 million.When the Stasi archives were opened to the public in the early 1990s, East Germans learned that there had been 986 documented deaths at the prison and discovered 112 miles worth of files on their fellow citizens.
Wow. “El que nace para tamal, del cielo le caen las hojas”
Accusations of the extreme repression in Cuba are usually shrugged off or dismissed as anti-Castro right wing, Batistiano hysteria. Not only that, the victims of the regime’s repression are often attacked by Castro supporters and apologists. The following excerpt hints at why those who have visited Cuba, may go on to become fervent Castro defenders and appologist as well as Cuban exile attackers-it’s all in the “tapes”.
Vázquez says he found the MININT is ''almost a copy'' of the repressive Stasi security system, exported by East Germany to Cuba in the 1970s and '80s, and that the ties between the two organizations run far deeper than previously known.From how to bug tourist hotel rooms to an intriguing mention of the hallucinogenic LSD, the degree to which the Stasi trained and provided material and technical support to the security arm of Fidel Castro's regime had a sweeping and harsh impact on Cuba.
Germans taught the Cubans how to mount effective camera and wiretap systems for eavesdropping -- for example, at what height on the wall to install microphones, which color wallpaper provides the best concealment, and which shade of lighting for the best video recordings.
“Dime con quien andas y te diré quien eres”
(crossposted in La Gusanera (La Contra Revolucion))
Posted by Gusano at November 5, 2007 11:11 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.babalublog.com/cgi-bin/mt/hut.cgi/6433
Comments
The only thing that will free Cuba is the people taking to the streets as in Venezuela. Cuba is a few short steps from surrendering her sovereignty to Venezuela and then it will be too late.
All the movements, letters, embargos, etc will not change Cuba. Yes they are needed if only in principal, but they will not change Cuba.
Cuba freedom will come at the price of blood. castro has kept them down with many tools among which one is hunger. They are going to die anyway. They might as well die in the name of freedom. Only the Cubans taking to the streets then taking the streets will free Cuba. Nothing less.
Posted by: pototo ![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.babalublog.com/nav-commenters.gif)
at November 5, 2007 12:51 PM
Maybe I'm misreading the author's tone, but I find a number of the suggestions in this post disturbing. And the comparisons with Venezuela are facile and a-historical.
Independent of the Cuban state's infiltration of dissident movements - which is undoubtedly pervasive - another important reason that a wider opposition struggle hasn't taken off in Cuba is simply the lack of resources. While emigration from Venezuela has increased since Chavez came to power, you have not seen anything close to the rapid exodus of professionals and others with means to financially support an opposition movement that you had in Cuba's case. True, NGOs, Cuban-American groups, and even the U.S. government attempt to support pro-democracy activists on the island. But in Venezuela, a sizable entrepreneurial class persists and pockets of private capital and resources are available, creating a much stronger base from which most opposition activity stems. In Cuba, this sector of society largely left the island and their resources were confiscated/nationalized much more aggressively than they have been in Venezuela's case.
(This should in no way be construed as criticism of those who left. I am the grandchild of one such individual and would never question his decision to leave the island.)
In short, how can you expect Cubans to mount a protest similar to that which occurred in Venezuela when they can't find let alone afford the poster paper necessary to make a simple sign that says "Abajo Fidel"? Materials aren't everything, but they certainly impact capacity-building.
In this context, demeaning the brave jovenes who wore the Cambio bracelets or downplaying the significance of their action is not only insulting, but also based on faulty comparative premises.
"We need protests like those. Thousands screaming with signs, tear gas, rubber bullets, brutality, beatings, blood."
Really? Thousands screaming, yes. But blood, bullets? Call me naive, but I refuse to believe that a successful transition, evolution, whatever you want to call it, can't occur peacefully. If Cuba is ever to overcome the many negative legacies of the Revolution, it must also overcome the legacy of violence and lawlessness that undermined Cuba's fledgling democracy before 1959. A number of leading dissidents - Payá in particular - would certainly agree.
Posted by: Busta at November 6, 2007 02:12 PM
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
